Dine In
Serves Beer
Serves Dinner
Serves Wine
Takeout
First time here at Foul Witch and it was honestly very surprising. I don't know much when it comes to Italian cuisine so my review doesn't have any frame...
2023-08-29 07:50:58
There has been so much hype about Foul Witch, whether it's the incredibly hard to get reservation, or just all the stories shared on IG. Finally got to go...
2023-10-10 09:12:12
So after jumping through all the requisite hoops one does to secure a reservation at one of New York's newer destination Foodie joints, we managed to score...
2023-09-29 12:44:03
The bread is amazing! Service is great and attentive. The server wine suggestion was great, as well. Portions are very small and, in my opinion, over price. Appetizers were good, nothing out of the ordinary. The pasta with crab was very good and flavorful. However, they give you a child's portion. The mushrooms' pasta I do not recommend it was not good at all, although I ate it since it was over 30 dollars for about 6 bite pieces. Did not stay for dessert
in the last week
Very cute spot with delicious food. Portions are small but filling, wine is great - even though you only have wine, beer and non alcoholic options. Definitely coming back! We got 2 apps and 4 mains for 5 people and it was enough. I wish we could have the dessert but we were full.
a month ago
A cute and cozy spot. As others mention, the portions are very small but the food is good. I found the desserts disappointing, but the appetizers and mains were good. I'd recommend coming here for small bites and a glass of wine. Great vibe to catch up with a friend or a date.
3 weeks ago
Absolutely wowed. Highly recommend. A little pricey but very worth it in my opinion. Wonderful wine selection as well and incredible staff!
a week ago
Definitely recommend going to Foul Witch for a fun date night or a wine night with a small group of friends! Food: •Fire & Ice - This dish is a dreamy combination of creamy stracciatella and spicy 'nduja sausage, which can be perfectly scooped up by their incredible bread. •Coppa - This thinly sliced, melt-in-your mouth Italian meat is a great pair for their delicious wines! •Sorana Beans - Do vourself a favor and treat vourself to this bowl of beans. The creamy white beans are doused in olive oil and a flavorful salsa verde. •Veal Tortellini - The texture of this dish is insane! These tortellini covered in amaretto are perfect pockets of fatness and flavor. •Sunchoke Caramelle - Love the intense lemon flavor here and the slight crunch from the poppyseeds! •Ice Cream - Foul Witch had a few creative ice cream flavors including a wildly savory Sourdough ice cream. Foul Witch has great wine and beer selections with some fun and rare finds! First we got a bottle of the 'Chette Baker skin-contact Gewürztraminer from Barbichette in the Finger Lakes. This wine was perfectly juicy with intense tropical fruit flavors of passion fruit and pineapple as well as notes of lychee, grapefruit, and spice. Highly recommend this wine, and it was a great value! Then we tried a super interesting co-ferment from Veneto, Italy made with Syrah, Grenache, and Garganega. The result is a punchy, light red wine with some serious acid!
3 months ago